Personally, I disagree with the authors assessment on the Enterprise’s anti-matter photons. Much more energy than a nuke.

And the sensors? Sorry, but way better on Enterprise.

Shields are also unaffected by standard kinetic weapons (nukes, etc.), so again I have to again give it to the Enterprise.

Ya, its geeky, but you like it anyway.

That gives the upper-hand to the Enterprise 6-1.